ARTICLE REVIEWER FORM
Jurnal Ilmiah Peuradeun
Article’s Title
*
Date of Article’s Reception:
*
-
Day
-
Month
Year
Date Picker Icon
Reviewer’s Name
*
Affiliation/ Institution
*
Address
Telp. and E-mail:
ARTICLE VIEW: Kindly tick in the provided space:
*
Rows
YES
NO
1. Is the paper content original?
2. Does the paper title represent its content?
3. Does the abstract reflect the paper content?
4. Do the keywords indicate the scope of the research?
5. Is the research methodology or approach to problem solving that used relevant and clear?
6. Do the data presentation and interpretation valid and reasonable?
7. Have the discussion and/or analysis been relevant with the results of the study?
8. Are the references used relevant?
9. Are there other existing paper related to this paper?
10. Are the paper’s quality, structure and grammar excellent and perfectly crafted?
11. Are there any parts of the manuscript that should be reduced or omitted? If there, please write your suggestions.
Papers Condition
*
Rows
Very Good
Good
Fair
Poor
1. Contribution to science
2. Originality
3. Systematic
4. Language
5. Writing accuracy
Please write your suggestions (If there)
Reviewers Acknowledgment. I hereby certify that I have reviewed this article at my utmost capacity and verify that the article should be:
*
Select
ACCEPTED
ACCEPTED for Publication WITH Revision
REJECTED
Finish date to be reviewed:
*
-
Day
-
Month
Year
Date Picker Icon
Enter the message as it's shown
*
Submit
Should be Empty: