Online Review Form for the Transactions on Science and Technology

Section I: Reviewer Information (Reviewer details will not be disclosed)

Reviewer's name*

First NameLast Name

Your Salutation

Affiliation*

Please enter your full affiliation name and address

E-Mail*

Please provide your email address

Section II: Article Details

Please select*

Rows	FIRST Review	SECOND Review	THIRD Review
Review Cycle

Title*

Copy and paste from the article reviewed

Author(s)*

Copy and paste from the article reviewed

Section III: Reviewing Outcome

Is the article of sufficient originality to warrant publication in the journal?*

YesNo

If No, please comments (if necessary, please do simple internet search for plagiarism/similarity to published articles)

Does the title reflect the content of the article? Please suggest new title if necessary at the "Constructive Feedback" section.*

YesNo

Is the abstract written well? (An abstract should provide short introduction, current research gap, objective, methodology, result and a conclusion)*

YesNo

Does the methodology describe what was done to answer the research question, how it was done, justify the experimental design, and explain how the results were analyzed?*

YesNo

Are the analyses and conclusions a logical outcome of the data and discussion?*

YesNo

Section IV: Final Recommendation

Please select your final recommendation*

Constructive feedback to the author(s) (Please specify recommendation for with minor and major correction)

Overall remarks (if any)

Upload file

Browse Files

Please upload here (less then 1MB) if you have supplementary reviewing document